6 min read

The (anti-)“hot take from Somerville”

My hope and energy come from possibility, not partisan victory.
Line drawing of a person with short black hair struggling under the weight of several dozen empty speech bubbles stacked high in their arms.
How it feels right now to read post-election hot takes. Illustration by Alghozy on Unsplash.

Bonus: Scroll to the P.S. for a special invitation.

I’m feeling very hopeful after the midterm elections. Not because of partisan victory, but because of possibility.

There are a million hot takes out there about the election. (I should know; I helped write one.)

Do these look familiar?

  • It was a blue wave. No, it was a blue tsunami. No, it was a red repudiation.
  • It was about data centers.
  • It was about the rent is too damn high and so is every other cost.
  • It was about the war in Iran. It was about war-like actions in Venezuela. It was about blowing up fishing boats and calling it “defense.” It was about Israel, Gaza, Palestine.
  • It was backlash to the anti-abortion movement, it was Blacklash to Southern gerrymandering, it was backlash to masked government agents kidnapping children.
  • It was about corruption, about billionaires and corporations trying to buy our elections, about the shameless grift and scammery of the Trump regime and its allies (see Habba, see Guilfoyle, see Don Jr., see the Qatari jet).
  • It was about voters getting sick of being told to blame problems that Washington could so clearly solve on people like meatpackers and home health aides and small children fleeing violence, or on people trying to live their true gender, or on people who don’t look like them next door or across the country or on the other side of the world.
  • It wasn’t backlash at all; it was the river of progress reclaiming its course from the right-wing backlash of the last decade. (One of my favorites by, duh, the glorious-brained Rebecca Solnit.)

There are Tweets, blog posts, long-form thinkpieces making the case that each of the above was the real decisive factor or the clearest lens through which to interpret the results.

Did I miss anything?


What if it was about all those things?

The Friday after the election, Danny and I were over at our friends’ house for Shabbat dinner in Jamaica Plain, far across the river from our home in Somerville. Naturally, we talked midterm results.

“Honestly, I know it was good news, but I’ve barely been following it,” Ruthy said. “I’m sure I’ll get the hot take from Somerville soon.”

It took me a second to realize she was talking about me and Purple Titanic. Kind of thrilling! The first time someone’s asked me for my hot take! (Yes, Ruthy, I realize that you didn’t, technically speaking, ask for it. I choose to interpret it as an invitation.)

So here goes—but in the spirit with which I first launched Purple T: as a place for exploration, for discussion-on-the-page, for “anti-hot-takes.” Which is to say, I’d love to know what you think of the reflections below, and what I’ve missed.

(And by the way, if you, like Ruthy, didn’t follow all the minutiae, scroll to the end for some of the lesser-known but significant outcomes.)

If I have a hot take, it’s this: There was no decisive factor in this election. It was about all of it.

Every one of the millions of people who cast ballots in this election had more than one thing on their minds. Like witnessing a neighbor be snatched by ICE and having to cut pricier items from the grocery list. Or seeing money siphoned from their kids’ public schools while fighting off a data center next door. Or watching fishermen be attacked by the U.S. military on TV, from a sweltering living room during a climate-change-intensified heat wave. And on and on.

If I have a hot take part 2, it’s this: It kind of doesn’t matter which of these was the key. What matters is that elected officials at every level and of every persuasion must now read the tea leaves: People want a lot of things to change, and the people who represent us should fight like hell for all of it.

Remember the post-2024 headlines? Democrats in crisis, the Democratic brand is dead, where do Democrats go from here? Two years is a long time, and there are a million ways for the Dems to screw this up, just as the Republicans found a million ways to screw things up in the last two years and now find themselves facing pretty much the same headlines.

Because if I have a third hot take, it’s this: What matters even more is that we make our reps make change. Last week, I joined a post-election webinar hosted by MediaJustice. They talked us through some of the lower-profile but high-impact wins and losses. (Scroll to the end for more.) But most importantly, they reminded us: “In this election, we didn’t pick our saviors. We picked our targets.” In other words, in two months, we’ll have more receptive people in power on the receiving end of our demands. We’ll need to keep showing up, keep packing town halls, keep sending our petitions and making our phone calls.

When I talked to Mom on Friday, my usual pre-Shabbat call, she was on her way back from a shift at the Eugene federal building, standing in the rain greeting people arriving for ICE check-ins and making sure that if they entered, they came back out. Later that evening, a woman at my synagogue told me about a post-election surge in ICE activity in Chelsea, a city just across the river from Boston with a large immigrant community, and how she’s coordinating protective-presence volunteers to stand outside the schools, grocery stores, and churches that ICE is targeting. A few months ago, after a Pilates class, the instructor warned us all that ICE agents had been spotted earlier raiding the apartment building next door, but “don’t worry,” she said, “I’ve already called the LUCE hotline,” and volunteers had already arrived on the scene.

All these examples (and more, beyond immigration) will likely still be necessary in the coming two years. Because many parts of this administration’s brutal agenda, including its ICE terror, are already a fully funded runaway train, one that will require even more pressure on a new Congress to rein in.

To be clear, this election gave me buckets of hope. I’ve been in a great mood for nearly two weeks. But moving forward, to butcher the old adage, I think we need to hope as though everything depends on Congress, and act as though everything depends on us.

One last thought: Focusing on what the election means for the future distracts us from the next two months, where a lot can still happen. The Trump regime and lame-duck Congress are doubling down on a bunch of shitty, unpopular things, like giving the architect of a fascist deportation agenda even more power, selling off our public lands to the highest bidder, and ramming through a dirty energy and data center buildout disguised as “permitting reform.” Speaking of which, if you do one thing today, let it be this.

So let’s fight like hell now to stop the bad, and let’s fight like hell come January to advance the good.

Did you know?

Here’s some of the good elections news you might have missed:

A final note

It’s Transgender Awareness Week, and unfortunately, the election results for the trans community are not all good news. Four states passed anti-trans measures by ballot initiative; two rejected them. So far in 2026, 63 anti-trans bills have passed around the country. But anti-trans advertising flopped spectacularly as an electoral strategy, and trans candidates notched historic victories from Michigan to Washington to rural Alabama and beyond. Which also gives me hope. It suggests that the moral panic against people’s freedom to be themselves is cresting. Voters will still oppose trans rights when it’s a discrete box they can casually check, and that’s hurting real people. But it’s no longer a top issue on voters’ minds, no longer decisive in elections. I think of the arc of gay marriage: Between 1994 and 2012, 33 out of 36 state-level ballot measures against same-sex marriage passed. But by the end of that time, similarly, being anti-gay had ceased to help candidates win. And less than three years later, the Supreme Court took marriage equality nationwide. I think—I hope—it’s entirely possible that we could be reaching a similar tipping point for trans equality (as long as we the people don’t let up!). To that end, this is a good week to donate to Advocates for Trans Equality.

*

What do you think?  I’d love to know what you’re celebrating, what you’re mourning, what I got wrong, all of it.

Love,

Ari

P.S. You know I’m always boosting my besties over at the Haus of Glitter, and this one is extra special: This Friday, they’re premiering The Historical Fantasy of America activist dance opera—guest starring none other than the queen of drag queens Latrice Royale. If you’ll be anywhere within three hours of Providence on Friday (sadly, I won’t), get your tickets now!